So much is being said about students in institutions, their political views and their 'precocious' actions. While looking through old pictures today, I was suddenly jolted by images from my own undergraduate institution. It made me think about why the 'bigger issue' is never addressed.
When I was in high school, I never really knew "what I wanted to be" when I got out. I had a vague idea that it would be something creative but that was the extent of it. My main priority was really to travel, go out, explore and live on my own. I would think about playing "Leaving on a Jet Plane" (even if I was, in fact,going to take a train to Bangalore) and thinking fondly about the memories I made in school while looking forward to great new ones.
The trajectory I ended up taking landed me in my hometown where I'd lived in for 17 years studying B.Sc Visual Communication in Women's Christian College. It was still exciting albeit a tad bit disappointing. I never really knew I'd go in an enthusiastic 17 year old and come out a confused, disillusioned 20 year old entirely insecure of my talents and abilities.
The reason I'm writing this right now is not to slander an old, respected institution but to inform people of the experiences I personally had before they decide to invest their money and more importantly their hopes and dreams into a college.
The Visual Communication course in WCC is self funded meaning there is no government aid for this particular course. This automatically makes it more expensive than the morning shift courses where students get a subsidized fee. The Visual Communication course is also, to my knowledge, the most expensive course on campus.
During the greater part of my first year in this course, there were no serious classes. For weeks on end, we were made to sit in a classroom purely for the purpose of having enough attendance to write our exams. Seeing me coming home every day more and more dejected, my parents did meet with the HoD to find out what was happening. They were told that the department was severely understaffed.
On more than one occasion movies were played to us. This was honestly, the most education we got that year.
Let's pause here for a second and look at the kind of syllabus that we were promised we'd be exposed to.
It looked promising in my mind. Every semester we would think that maybe the next one will be better.
For the most part, those years are now a blur. I do remember photography classes quite distinctly seeing as images were the first real passion I encountered in my life. Every day, we would be asked to take pictures of things inside the campus. It would mostly end up being flowers, trees and a dog called Bob. This practice continued even when I foolishly picked Advanced Photography as my elective. When I went on to do my Master's course in Cinematography in Bournemouth University, I didn't know what white balance was. After 2 years of both Basic and Advanced Photography, my understanding of white balance was just a bunch of jargon that made no sense to me until I'd messed up in my Masters and learned from it.
There was a procedure to submit final stills for the exam. We were given different subjects and had to take photographs accordingly on our own time. Before final submissions, we were to show a set of pictures under each heading to our teacher for approval.
This was one of the pictures I submitted under the title of 'Animal Photography'. She rejected it saying "the whole animal has to be seen".
This sort of thing used to happen on a daily basis. Take some pictures. Get excited about some of them. Show it to the teacher only to be belittled. It became a phobia. I remember once getting into a huge argument over some photos taken with lighting in a studio. I can take criticism, I accept it wholeheartedly. But the source loses credibility when they are the only ones who constantly and flippantly dissuade you. Today I find myself unable to judge my own work. I find myself thinking nothing is good enough and am either disbelieving or in wonder when someone compliments me for it.
When it came to Television Production, we got the big gun herself. The HoD taught us the subject. Again a bunch of terms we had to learn by heart and write an exam on. You might say this happens in every institution. What probably doesn't happen is instructing each student to make a 10-15 minute film on their own and not even taking the time to see them. It wasn't just her, the external examiner who watched my film stopped watching at 3 minutes.
I could go on. I could quote instances where there was a gross misuse of power, of insensitive teachers and power-drunk disciplinarians. This is all not new. I'm sure people have bad experiences in a lot of colleges across Chennai, maybe even in India. But nobody wants to talk about it. We get busy with our lives. We try to figure out how to pick up the pieces of broken aspirations and glue them back together to form a semblance of what it used to be before we went through the college system. Or for some, it's just the question of getting a degree and getting out. It's idealistic to expect an actual education from an institute.
I don't profess to know anything about teaching and respect those qualified to do so. I would even go so far as to say I think it is a very important pillar for the foundation of any society. Here is the question though.
Why are so many of the young people coming out of institutions feeling under equipped and incompetent? Isn't education supposed to strengthen you? Give you creative freedom and a licence to think for yourself?
If a person like me, born into a comfortable, well read family, who has been exposed to different cultures had a huge dip in morale after coming out of university, what is the fate of others who aren't as lucky as I am? I spent 3 years, sitting outside classrooms giving my classmates summaries of everything that had been taught in class before almost every single exam. I don't say this to brag. I know it makes me sound like a nerd. I say this because I, an ill-equipped student, had to 'teach' my friends what the 'teachers' had already 'taught' them.
I remember a conversation during our second year, when a third year student told us that we should get out when we can. Switch to some other college, any other. Don't even worry that you'll 'lose' 2 years of your life. Of course we just wanted to get done with it having come so far.
I remember having arguments with my Photography teacher almost on a daily basis and struggling to defend my work without having any theoretical knowledge of how to. And mostly I remember constantly having conversations with my friends about how frustrated we were with the lack of absolutely anything to do. But I realise now that maybe we as a society are being programmed not to think. Doesn't social media conform us enough without education institutions crushing every creative thought and every smidgen of individuality?
And I remember that's how it was in school as well, although not as extreme and not incompetently so.
We weren't given information and given time to process that information. We were given information and given time to by-heart it.
So here's my point to all this.
I propose we start thinking about why we're spending money and time and submitting ourselves over to a particular institution. And maybe we don't sit quiet about experiences.
I think it's sometimes this voice inside us that tells us we're lucky that we're even getting an education and other people have it worse. Maybe we should tell that voice to keep quiet for a while and think about how many future, young 'us-es' our silence is affecting.


No comments:
Post a Comment